First Circuit Rules in Favor of Petitioner in Jabri

The United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit rendered its decision in the case of Abdallah Jabri v. Holder on March 16, 2012. The Appeals Court ruled that the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) erred when it upheld the holding of an immigration judge (IJ) that the petitioner, a native and citizen of Jordan, had not  made credible claims and therefore denied him asylum, withholding of removal, and protection under the Convention Against Torture (CIA). Petitioner had appealed on the basis that the IJ and BIA had ignored material portions of evidence that supported his claim while focusing on minor and nonexistent inconsistencies to deny him relief. The Court agreed with the Petitioner, holding that "The IJ must...present a reasoned analysis of the evidence as a whole. We are not satisfied that the IJ has done so here."


Petitioner and his family entered the United States and lived in New Hampshire when he was a child. They overstayed their visas and  removal proceedings were initiated against Petitioner in April 2009. However, Petitioner and his family had converted from Islam to Christianity during their years living in the United States and Petitioner feared he would be persecuted on account of his conversion if he entered Jordan. The Court noted "There was evidence that the Jordanian constitution stipulates that Muslims' personal status is governed by Islamic law, according to which apostasy may be punished by an inability to own property, find employment, marry, or maintain custody of one's children." Petitioner also feared his grandfather, a prominent member of the Islamic community, would instigate an honor killing against him for converting to Christianity. 


For more on this case, click here. 

Glickman Turley's experienced attorneys represent individuals on a wide range of immigration matters, as well as other legal issues. Please contact our attorneys if you wish to discuss representation on immigration matters, real estate purchase and sales, condominium associations, criminal defense, non-profit law, civil litigation, business litigation, business law, trademark law, probate matters including wills, powers of attorney, health care proxy, same-sex parent adoptions, guardianships, animal law, or LGBT legal matters.